Skip to main content

3. Documented Case Studies

Case studies overview

The following cases are drawn from DOJ press releases, criminal complaints, appellate records, regulatory findings, and court judgments. Each entry documents:

  1. What happened
  2. Signals present in retrospect
  3. What was missed
  4. What triggered detection
  5. Key detection lesson

Secondary press sources are used only where primary documents are not publicly accessible.

Case Index

#ActorOrganisationCategoryDetection Trigger
3.1Chelsea ManningUS ArmyEspionage / mass exfiltrationHuman tip
3.2Edward SnowdenNSA / Booz Allen HamiltonEspionage / data exfiltrationJournalistic publication
3.3Roger DuronioUBS PaineWebberSabotage (logic bomb)Destructive execution
3.4Anthony LevandowskiWaymo → UberDeparting employee / IP theftCivil litigation discovery
3.5Sudhish Kasaba RameshCisco SystemsSabotage / post-terminationService outage
3.6Xiaoqing ZhengGE AviationEspionage / IP theftFBI counterintelligence referral
3.7Andrew SkeltonMorrisonsDisgruntled / data exfiltrationNewspaper contact
3.8Reyes Daniel RuizYahooPrivilege abuse / misuseEmployer observation
3.9Nickolas SharpUbiquitiData theft / extortionVPN failure / OPSEC error
3.10Volodymyr KvashukMicrosoftFinancial fraudInternal anomaly detection
3.11[Employee]Desjardins GroupData exfiltrationPolice notification
3.12[Former employees]TeslaDeparting employee / exfiltrationNewspaper contact
3.13Abouammo / AlzabarahTwitterInsider espionage / state-sponsoredManagement observation
3.14Juliana BarileNY Credit UnionSabotage / post-terminationData loss discovery
Pattern Summary

Of 14 cases, initial detection came from human observation, external notification, law enforcement referral, or operational failure in the large majority of cases. Internal technical monitoring was the primary trigger in at most 2–3 (Kvashuk, arguably Twitter/Alzabarah and Yahoo/Ruiz).

This is not a statistically representative sample — it is directionally consistent with CERT's 61%/22% finding across sectors.